Securities and Exchange Commission
Litigation Release No. 18117 / April 28, 2003
Securities and Exchange Commission v. Morgan Stanley & Co.
Incorporated, 03 CV 2948 (WHP) (S.D.N.Y.)
SEC SUES MORGAN STANLEY FOR RESEARCH ANALYST CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
FIRM TO SETTLE WITH SEC, NASD, NYSE, NY ATTORNEY GENERAL, AND STATE
REGULATORS
The Securities and Exchange Commission announced today that it has
settled charges against Morgan Stanley & Co. Incorporated, a New
York-based brokerage firm and investment bank, arising from an
investigation of research analyst conflicts of interest. This
settlement, and settlements with nine other brokerage firms, are part
of the global settlement the firms have reached with the Commission,
NASD, Inc., the New York Stock Exchange, Inc. ("NYSE"), the New York
Attorney General, and other state regulators. As part of the
settlement, Morgan Stanley has agreed to pay $25 million as
disgorgement and an additional $25 million in penalties. One-half of
the total of these payments - $25 million - will be paid in connection
with the SEC action and related proceedings by the NASD and NYSE and
will be placed into a distribution fund for the benefit of customers
of the firm. The remainder will be paid to resolve related proceedings
by state regulators. In the SEC action, Morgan Stanley has agreed to a
federal court order that will enjoin the firm from future violations
of NASD and NYSE rules and require the firm to make changes in the
operations of its equity research and investment banking departments.
In addition, Morgan Stanley will pay, over five years, $75 million to
provide the firm's clients with independent research.
In connection with this matter, the Commission today filed a Complaint
against Morgan Stanley in the U.S. District Court for the Southern
District of New York, alleging violations of NASD and NYSE rules.
According to the Commission's Complaint, from at least July 1999
through June 2001, research analysts at Morgan Stanley were subject to
inappropriate influence by investment banking at the firm. The
Complaint also alleges that Morgan Stanley made payments to other
firms for those firms to publish research on Morgan Stanley's
underwriting clients without ensuring that such payments were
disclosed and failed to maintain appropriate supervision over its
research and investment banking operations.
Specifically, the Commission's Complaint alleges that
* Morgan Stanley compensated its research analysts, in part, based
on the degree to which they helped generate investment banking
business for the firm. As part of the annual performance
SNIPPETS:
Securities and Exchange Commission
Securities and Exchange Commission v. Morgan Stanley & Co. Incorporated,
SEC SUES MORGAN STANLEY FOR RESEARCH ANALYST CONFLICTS OF INTEREST FIRM TO SETTLE WITH SEC,
The Securities and Exchange Commission announced today that it has settled charges against
This settlement, and settlements with nine other brokerage firms, are part of the global
One-half of the total of these payments - $25 million - will be paid in connection with the
The remainder will be paid to resolve related proceedings by state regulators.
Morgan Stanley has agreed to a federal court order that will enjoin the firm from future
In connection with this matter, the Commission today filed a Complaint against Morgan Stanley
According to the Commission's Complaint, from at least July 1999 through June 2001, research
The Complaint also alleges that Morgan Stanley made payments to other firms for those firms
Specifically, the Commission's Complaint alleges that * Morgan Stanley compensated its
Pitchbooks used by Morgan Stanley to solicit investment banking business routinely described
For example, some pitchbooks identified a particular analyst's history of issuing Strong Buy
Morgan Stanley's lack of an effective review system allowed certain analysts to maintain
The final judgment also orders the firm to make the payments described above, and provides
In addition, the final judgment orders Morgan Stanley to implement structural reforms and
Morgan Stanley has agreed to sever the links between research and investment banking, such
ating in efforts to solicit investment banking business, including pitches and roadshows.
In addition, Morgan Stanley must disclose on the first page of each research report whether
|