LegalCaseDocs.com
shopping cart  
  |     
Search
 

 
New Visitors


 VeriSign Secure Site

 Get Adobe Reader

IN THE MATTER OF ARTHUR T. FARBER v CITY OF UTICA Click to find out why . . .



Keywords & Phrases
CourtCode: AP, CourtName: NEW YORK COURT OF APPEALS, Plaintiff: IN THE MATTER OF ARTHUR T. FARBER, State: NEW YORK, UniqueCaseRef: NE>AP>I02_0024, Retirement, Pension, General Municipal Law, Supplemental Allowance, Social Security Law, Amount, Disability Pension, City, Payment, Farber, Statutory, Firefighters, Obligation, Pursuant, Counterclaim, Legislature, Matter, Appellants, York State, Phrase, Fire, Supreme Court, Wages, Accidental Disability, Cost, Amendment, Calculating, Living Adjustment, Base Pension , ContentID: 120251770

Case Documents
1 2002-03-14 OPINION
[ see first page and extracted highlights below  ] ItemID: 125679
4 pages
HTML
Total Documents: 1 document , 4 pages
Price: $ 19.95


IVESLCD01 KGI0001
 
 

 Forgot your password?


1 . OPINION

EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
LAW
PENSION
GENERAL MUNICIPAL LAW
SUPPLEMENTAL ALLOWANCE
SOCIAL SECURITY LAW
AMOUNT
DISABILITY PENSION
CITY
PAYMENT
FARBER
STATUTORY
FIREFIGHTERS
OBLIGATION
PURSUANT
COUNTERCLAIM
LEGISLATURE
MATTER
APPELLANTS
YORK STATE
PHRASE
FIRE
SUPREME COURT
WAGES
ACCIDENTAL DISABILITY
COST
AMENDMENT
CALCULATING
LIVING ADJUSTMENT
BASE PENSION


   4 No. 26
   In the Matter of Arthur T. Farber,
   Respondent,
   v.
   City of Utica and Barbara B. Barry, &c.,
   Appellants.
     _________________________________________________________________

   2002 NY Int. 24

   March 14, 2002

   This opinion is uncorrected and subject to revision before publication
   in the New York Reports.

   Charles N. Brown, for appellants.
   Mark A. Wolber, for respondent.
   New York State Conference of Mayors and Municipal Officials, amicus
   curić.
     _________________________________________________________________

   CIPARICK, J.:

   On this appeal we are asked to determine a municipality's retirement
   payment obligation under General Municipal Law § 207-a. More
   precisely, the issue is whether the phrase "amounts received," in
   section 207-a(2) of the General Municipal Law, includes both base
   pension benefits and supplemental entitlements received pursuant to
   the Retirement and Social Security Law. We hold that it does.

   Arthur T. Farber is a retired City of Utica firefighter. He was hired
   in March 1973 and in May 1973 was seriously injured in the line of
   duty while fighting a fire. The injury left Farber permanently
   disabled and on October 18, 1980, the City involuntarily retired him.
   Consequently, Farber receives disability retirement benefits from
   three distinct statutory sources.

   Pursuant to Retirement and Social Security Law § 363-c, he receives an
   annual disability pension from the New York State Retirement System.
   Pursuant to General Municipal Law § 207-a, he also receives from
   the City the difference between the State disability pension and the
   salary of active firefighters.

   This appeal centers on the third statutory source of Farber's
   benefits. Pursuant to Retirement and Social Security Law § 378, Farber
   receives a supplemental allowance from the State.(1) Originally,
SNIPPETS:
  • Charles N. Brown, for appellants.
  • More precisely, the issue is whether the phrase "amounts received," in section 207-aof the
  • Arthur T. Farber is a retired City of Utica firefighter.
  • Farber receives disability retirement benefits from three distinct statutory sources.
  • Pursuant to Retirement and Social Security Law § 363-c, he receives an annual disability
  • Pursuant to General Municipal Law § 207-a, he also receives from the City the difference
  • Pursuant to Retirement and Social Security Law § 378, Farber receives a supplemental
  • Farber commenced an article 78 proceeding to compel the City to recalculate its obligation
  • In 1977, the Legislature amended General Municipal Law § 207-a, effecting dramatic changes in
  • The amendment sought to "substantially reduce the financial burden of municipalities with
  • If a firefighter is granted "an accidental disability retirement allowance," pursuant to
  • In Matter of Mashnouk v Miles ), this Court held that the phrase "'regular salary or wages' *
  • The City's payment obligation is determined by calculating the total "amounts received" by
  • This automatic pay adjustment obviates the need for a distinct and additional supplemental
  • Accordingly, the order of the Appellate Division should be reversed, with costs, the petition
  • Effective July 11, 2000, the Legislature enacted an automatic cost of living adjustment.
  •    |