LegalCaseDocs.com
shopping cart  
  |     
Search
 

 
New Visitors


 VeriSign Secure Site

 Get Adobe Reader

HALE O KAULA CHURCH v THE MAUI PLANNING COMMISSION Click to find out why . . .



Keywords & Phrases
CaseNo: HOKCVTMPC246227, Plaintiff: HALE O KAULA CHURCH, State: CT Connecticut, UniqueCaseRef: LCD>HOKCVTMPC246227, Church, Hawaii, County, Maui Planning Commission, Land, Planning Commission, Maui, Commission, Capacity, Hearing Officer, Maui Planning, United States, City, Agriculture, Thomas Foster, Elder, Kaula, Hale, Hurd, Religious Exercise, Cir, Neustadter Fuqua, Benjamin Cayetano, Maui Department, United States Constitution, David Jenkins, Paragraphs, Anthony Ching, Kaula Church, Judith Neustadter Fuqua, Samuel Kalalau, Free Exercise, Rluipa, Apana, Reference, Fire Protection, Jon Thuro , ContentID: 120250077

Case Documents
1   AMENDED COMPLAINT
[ see first page and extracted highlights below  ] ItemID: 131102
26 pages
PDF
2 2002-01-30 PLTFFS NOTICE OF HEARING MOTION
[ see first page and extracted highlights below  ] ItemID: 123851
100 pages
PDF
Total Documents: 2 documents , 126 pages
Price: $ 24.95


IVESLCD01 KGI0001
 
 

 Forgot your password?


1 . AMENDED COMPLAINT

EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
PLAINTIFFS
DEFENDANTS
MAUI PLANNING COMMISSION
HAWAII
PLANNING COMMISSION
COUNTY
UNITED STATES
LAND
KAULA
HALE
NEUSTADTER FUQUA
CAPACITY
AGRICULTURE
MEMBERS
HEARING OFFICER
UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION
THOMAS FOSTER
PARAGRAPHS
JUDITH NEUSTADTER FUQUA
SAMUEL KALALAU
ATTORNEYS
REFERENCE
FIRE PROTECTION
BENJAMIN CAYETANO
JON THURO
DISCRIMINATING
AGRICULTURAL BUILDING
MAUI COUNTY CODE
DEPRIVE PLAINTIFFS
THE BECKET FUND FOR RELIGIOUS LIBERTY
ROMAN STORZER (D.C. # 459878)
ANTHONY PICARELLO (D.C.  # 454459)
1350 Connecticut Avenue, NW, Ste 605
Washington, D.C.  20036-1735
Telephone:  (202) 955-0095
(Applications Pro Hac Vice Pending)

HURD & LURIA
CHARLES H. HURD (HI  # 1702)
City Financial Tower, 1500
201 Merchant Street
Honolulu, Hawaii 96813
Telephone: (808) 524-0325

Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Hale O Kaula Church, Daryl Arita, Elder;
Thomas Foster, Elder; David Jenkins,
Elder; and Robert Poulson, Elder

                         IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                               FOR THE DISTRICT OF HAWAII

HALE O KAULA CHURCH, DARYL                    :   CIVIL NO. _____________________
ARITA, Elder; THOMAS FOSTER,                  :
Elder; DAVID JENKINS, Elder; and              :   COMPLAINT; DEMAND FOR JURY
ROBERT POULSON, Elder;                        :   TRIAL; SUMMONS
                                              :
   Plaintiffs,
                                       :
                                              :
               v.                             :
                                              :
The MAUI PLANNING COMMISSION;  :
SAMUEL KALALAU III, JEREMY F.  :
KOZUKI, BERNICE LU, STAR                      :
MEDEIROS, SUSAN MOIKEHA,                      :
HERMAN NASCIMENTO, RANDY                      :
PILTZ, JOSEPH PONTANILLA,                     :
MONA RICHARDSON, in their                     :
individual capacities and in their            :
official capacities as members of the         :
Maui Planning Commission; JOHN E.   :
MIN, in his individual capacity and in his :
official capacity as the Director of the      :
Maui Department of Planning;                  :
THE COUNTY OF MAUI, HAWAII;                   :


SNIPPETS:
  • Attorneys for Plaintiffs
  • Maui Planning Commission; JOHN E.: MIN, in his individual capacity and in his: official
  • capacity as Mayor of the County of Maui:
  • HAWAII; BENJAMIN CAYETANO, in: his official capacity as the Governor of:
  • Comes now the Plaintiffs Hale O Kaula Church, Daryl Arita,
  • Thomas Foster, David Jenkins, and Robert Poulson, by and through their attorneys, and for
  • protection of the laws by the Defendants.
  • the United States and Hawaii Constitutions, the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized
  • through the Hawaii Revised Statutes and Maui County Code provisions preventing churches
  • against Hale O Kaula and its members based on religious prejudice.
  • Defendant Samuel Kalalau III is a member of the Maui Planning Commission.
  • Defendant Judith Neustadter Fuqua is a hearing officer for the Maui Planning
  • of local ecosystems through the use of perennial agriculture;
  • location, in addition to the cost of the property, the residence, and the agricultural
  • Jon Thuro followed invited guests onto the Church's
  • in the municipality in terms of the provision of water, police, and fire protection.
  • United States Constitution and the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act,
  • Paragraphs 1 through 106 are incorporated by reference as if set forth fully herein.
  • Defendants have deprived and continue to deprive Plaintiffs of their right to be
  • applicable to the States by the Fourteenth Amendment, by discriminating against Plaintiffs

  • 2 . PLTFFS NOTICE OF HEARING MOTION

    EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
    CHURCH
    PLAINTIFFS
    MAUI
    LAND
    COMMISSION
    COUNTY
    MAUI PLANNING
    CITY
    CAPACITY
    HEARING OFFICER
    MEMBERS
    ELDER
    HURD
    RELIGIOUS EXERCISE
    CIR
    THOMAS FOSTER
    DEFENDANTS
    AGRICULTURE
    MAUI DEPARTMENT
    DAVID JENKINS
    ANTHONY CHING
    KAULA CHURCH
    FREE EXERCISE
    RLUIPA
    ATTORNEYS
    APANA
    BENJAMIN CAYETANO
    UNITED STATES
    STRICT SCRUTINY
    
    THE BECKET FUND FOR RELIGIOUS LIBERTY
    ROMAN STORZER (D.C. # 459878)
    ANTHONY PICARELLO (D.C.  # 454459)
    1350 Connecticut Avenue, NW, Ste 605
    Washington, D.C.  20036-1735
    Telephone:  (202) 955-0095
    (Applications Pro Hac Vice Pending)
     HURD & LURIA
    CHARLES H. HURD (HI  # 1702)
    City Financial Tower, 1500
    201 Merchant Street
    Honolulu, Hawaii 96813
    Telephone: (808) 524-0325
      Attorneys for Plaintiffs
    Hale O Kaula Church, Daryl Arita, Elder;
    Thomas Foster, Elder; David Jenkins,
    Elder; and Robert Poulson, Elder
    
                                   IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
    
                                           FOR THE DISTRICT OF HAWAII
    
    HALE O KAULA CHURCH, DARYL                                CIVIL NO. 01-00615 SPK KSC
    ARITA, Elder; THOMAS FOSTER,
    Elder; DAVID JENKINS, Elder; and                         PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE OF HEARING
    ROBERT POULSON, Elder;                                   MOTION; PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR
                                                             A PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION;
                                      Plaintiffs,            MORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF
                                                             PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR A
     v.                                                      PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION;
                                                             DECLARATION OF THOMAS FOSTER;
    THE MAUI PLANNING                                        DECLARATION OF DAVID JENKINS;
    COMMISSION; SAMUEL KALALAU                               EXHIBIT "A"; DECLARATION OF
    III, JEREMY F. KOZUKI, BERNICE                           CHARLES H. HURD; EXHIBITS "B" -
    LU, STAR MEDEIROS, SUSAN                                 "N"; CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
    
    MOIKEHA, HERMAN NASCIMENTO,
    RANDY PILTZ, JOSEPH                                      DATE        :   January 30, 2002
    PONTANILLA, MONA RICHARDSON,                             TIME        :  10:00 a.m.
    individually and in their official capacities            JUDGE       :   Samuel P. King
    as members of the Maui Planning
    Commission; JOHN E. MIN, the Director                    TRIAL DATE: s  None Set
    of the Maui Department of Planning; THE
    
    
    
         COUNTY OF MAUI, HAWAII; JAMES
         APANA JR., in his official capacity as
         Mayor of the County of Maui; JUDITH
    
    SNIPPETS:
  • HURD & LURIA CHARLES H. HURD
  • City Financial Tower, 1500
  • Hawaii 96813 Telephone: 524-0325 Attorneys for Plaintiffs
  • Hale O Kaula Church, Daryl Arita, Elder; Thomas Foster, Elder; David Jenkins,
  • of the Maui Department of Planning;
  • Mayor of the County of Maui;
  • capacity as Hearing Officer for the Maui
  • Planning Commission; STATE OF
  • State of Hawaii; THE LAND USE
  • THE MAUI PLANNING COMMISSION, SAMUEL KALALAU III, JEREMY F.
  • individually and in their official capacities as members of the Maui Planning
  • Planning, THE COUNTY OF MAUI, HAWAII, JAMES APANA JR., in his official
  • individually and in her official capacity as Hearing Officer for the Maui Planning
  • Hawaii 96813 Attorneyfor Defendants
  • STATE OF HAWAII, BENJAMIN CAYETANO in his official capacity as the Governor of the State of
  • NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the above-entitled Plaintiffs' Motion
  • Otherwise using the Property for purposes of religious exercise.
  • Free Exercise Clause: Lack of Neutrality
  • 714 F.2d 962 (9th Cir.
  • Native Village of Quinhagak v. United States,
  • Constitutions, RLUIPA, and Hawaii law.
  • Hale O Kaula Church is a small, nondenominational congregation that has been holding
  • accompanying Declarations of Plaintiffs David Jenkins and Thomas Foster
  • The Property is located within the State Agricultural District, is identified as
  • Strict scrutiny analysis is appropriate for Plaintiffs' Free Exercise claims for six
  •    |