LegalCaseDocs.com
shopping cart  
  |     
Search
 

 
New Visitors


 VeriSign Secure Site

 Get Adobe Reader

UNITED STATES SURGICAL CORPORATION v AUHLL Click to find out why . . .



Keywords & Phrases
CaseNo: C.A. No. 15,223, CourtCode: CC, CourtName: IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE, Plaintiff: UNITED STATES SURGICAL CORPORATION, State: DE Delaware, UniqueCaseRef: DE>CC>00015223, Del, Motion, Circon, Judgement, Costs, Fees, Supr, Discovery, Amended Complaint, Delaware, Interrogatories, Dismiss, Auhll, Shareholders, Opposition, Brvson, Directors, Lockwood Aff, Circon Board, Preliminary Injunction, Reelection, Proxy Statement, Reappointing, Expedite, Surgical Corn, Responses, Thompson, Diboise David, Wilson Sonsini Goodrich, Election, Requests, Stockholders, Enjoin, Arbitrary Deadline, Annual Meeting, Slate, Relief, Vote, Proceeding, Summary Judgment, Voting , ContentID: 120241049

Case Documents
1 1998-04-22 DEFENDANTS ANSWERING BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION
[ see first page and extracted highlights below  ] ItemID: 103362
17 pages
PDF
2 1997-09-17 LETTER OPINION
[ see first page and extracted highlights below  ] ItemID: 114934
6 pages
PDF
Total Documents: 2 documents , 23 pages
Price: $ 24.95


IVESLCD01 KGI0001
 
 

 Forgot your password?


1 . DEFENDANTS ANSWERING BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION

EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
DEFENDANTS
DEL
MOTION
JUDGEMENT
COURT
FEES
SUPR
COSTS
DISCOVERY
AMENDED COMPLAINT
DELAWARE
INTERROGATORIES
CIRCON
DISMISS
OPPOSITION
BRVSON
LOCKWOOD AFF
CIRCON BOARD
SURGICAL CORN
LITIGATION
RESPONSES
THOMPSON
DIBOISE DAVID
WILSON SONSINI GOODRICH
REQUESTS
DIRECTORS
ARBITRARY DEADLINE
ANNUAL MEETING
SUMMARY JUDGMENT
.                        IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
L-
,                                     IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY                            46
; .
r .            UNITED STATES SURGICAL
                CORPORATION, a Delaware corporation,          ;
                and IJSS ACQUISITION CORP., a Delaware        )
i :             corporation,
                                                              ;
                                                Plaintiffs,  )
                                                              >
                                      V.                      ) C.A.NO. 15223                 .-
                                                                                        -.
                RICHARD A. AUHLL, R. BRUCE                    i
                THOMPSON, HAROLD R. FRANK,
                RUDOLF R. SCHULTE, PAUL W.                    ;
                HARTLOFF, JR., JOHN BLOKKER,
                GEORGE A. CLOUTIER, and CIRCON                ;
                CORPORATION, a Delaware corporation,
                                                              ;
                                              Defendants.  )


                          DEFENDANTS' ANSWERING BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO
                                PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR DEFAULT JUDGMENT

                                                          Jesse A. Finkelstein
                                                          Raymond J. DiCamillo
                                                          Richards, Layton & Finger
                                                          One Rodney Square
                                                          P.O. Box 55 1
                                                          Wilmington, Delaware 19899
                                                          (302) 658-6541
                                                           Attorneys for Defendants
       OF COUNSEL:

       James A. DiBoise
       David J. Berger
       Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati
       Professional Corporation
       650 Page Mill Road
       Palo Alto, California 94304-1050
       (650) 4934300


       Dated: April 22, 1998

       FcLFl-162600-l

SNIPPETS:
  • DEFENDANTS' ANSWERING BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO
  • James A. DiBoise David J. Berger
  • Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati Professional Corporation
  • PLAINTIFFS ARE NOT ENTITLED TO ANY FEES OR COSTS.
  • DelawareSand & Gravel Co. v. Brvson,
  • Supr., 337 A.2d 651.
  • U.S. Surgical Corn.
  • Court ofchancery Rule 55.
  • defendant Circon Corporation.
  • After the Circon board of directors unanimously voted to .--; recommend that its stockholders
  • plaintiffs' motion is based upon defendants'
  • The extraordinary remedy of default judgment is unavailable.
  • Unfortunately, with a fact discovery
  • plaintiffs continued to do nothing to move this litigation forward.
  • defeated in his bid for re-election at the annual meeting,
  • Circon board under Delaware law and the Circon charter and by-laws to expand the number
  • Cloutier and R. Bruce Thompson to the Circon board.
  • the amended complaint speculated about Mr. Auhll's defeat at the annual meeting
  • Since the filing of the motion to dismiss,
  • providing inadequate responses to defendants' first set of interrogatories,
  • `Citations to "Lockwood Aff."
  • and arbitrary deadline of April 3.
  • expressed skepticism that this action could be resolved on a motion for summary judgment.
  • II.,PLA,INTIFFS ARE NOT ENTITLED TO ANY FEES OR COSTS.
  • 81 requests:for admission.

  • 2 . LETTER OPINION

    EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
    AUHLL
    SHAREHOLDERS
    PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION
    REELECTION
    PROXY STATEMENT
    REAPPOINTING
    EXPEDITE
    MEETING
    ELECTION
    STOCKHOLDERS
    ENJOIN
    SLATE
    RELIEF
    DIRECTORS
    VOTE
    PROCEEDING
    VOTING
    IRREPARABLE HARM
    COURT
    COSTS
    ESQUIRE
    PLAINTIFFS
    SCHEDULE
    PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION HEARING
    NOMINEES
    INCUMBENT BOARD
    DEFENDANTS
    APPOINTING
    NECESSITATING
    
    WILLIAM  B.  CHANOLER  ii1
           CHANCELLOR                                 September   17,  199'7         CHANCERY 
                                                                                             P.O. BOX 
                                                                                     GEORGETOWN. 
    
    
            -mA FAX 2% FIRST CLASS MAIL
    
            Thomas  J.  Allingham,  Esquire
            Skadden,  Arps, Slate,  Meagher  &  Flom
            P.O.  Box  636
            Wiimington.,  DE  19899
    
            Jesse A.  Finkelstein, Esquire
            Raymond  J.  DiCamillo, Esquire
            Richards,  Layton  &  Finger
            P.O.  Box  551
            Wilmington.,  DE  19899
    
                                  Re:    U.S.  Surgical  Corp.  v.  Circon  Corp.
                                         Civil  Action  No.  15223
    
            Dear Counsel:                                                                              
    
                     Plaintiffs  United  States  Surgical  Corporation   and  USS  Acquisition
    
            Corporation  (together  "US Surgical") have moved for  an  order that  would  grant
    
            expedited  discovery and  schedule  a  preliminary injunction hearing for  a  date  on
    
            or  before  September  26,  1997. US  Surgical  seeks  this  emergency  relief  in
    
            connection  with  the  October  6,  1997,  annual meeting at  which stockholders  will
    
            elect  two  directors  to  the  Board  of  Circon  Corporation  ("Circon"),   choosing
    
            between   US  Surgical's  slate  of  nominees  and  Circon's   slate,  which  includes
    
            Circon's  chief executive officer and incumbent board member, defendant Richard
    
    
    
    A,:  4uhll.  I  JS  Surgical  seeks  to  preliminarily  enjoin  defendants  fi+!-.  appointing
    
    h4r.  Auhll  to  the  Circon  Board  of  Directors   in  the  event  that  he  is  not  reelected
    
    to  Circon's  Board  at  the  October   6,  1997,  annual  stockholder  meeting.
    
              The  background  against   which  the  motion  to  expedite  is  made  is  as
    
    SNIPPETS:
  • Jesse A. Finkelstein, Esquire Raymond J. DiCamillo, Esquire
  • Plaintiffs United States Surgical Corporation and USS Acquisition
  • expedited discovery and schedule a preliminary injunction hearing for a date on
  • between US Surgical's slate of nominees and Circon's slate,
  • Circon's chief executive officer and incumbent board member,
  • I JS Surgical seeks to preliminarily enjoin defendants fi+!-.
  • Auhll to the Circon Board of Directors in the event that he is not reelected
  • to Circon's Board at the October 6, 1997, annual stockholder meeting.
  • The background against which the motion to expedite is made is as
  • On Se:ptember 11, 1997, Circon issued a proxy statement to shareholders
  • US Surgical contends that immediate injunctive relief is
  • necessary to prevent an irreparable deprivation of the stockholders' fundamental
  • right to vote: for, or against, directors.
  • upcoming election is "inherently coercive and will irreparably taint the electoral
  • that voting would be an exercise in futility.
  • than cast "futile" votes in favor of the US Surgical nominees and against Mr.
  • contributing to Mr. Auhll's reelection.
  • adjudication until the shareholders actually vote him off the Board ancJ the newlyconstituted
  • US Surgical's theory of irreparable harm is based on
  • Far from necessitating .the requested expedited relief,
  • The Court is not able or even required at this juncture to determine the
  • the Court will decline to impose the costs
  • associated with such a proceeding.
  •    |