LegalCaseDocs.com
shopping cart  
  |     
Search
 

 
New Visitors


 VeriSign Secure Site

 Get Adobe Reader

GOWER v PRIMAVERA LABORATORIES Click to find out why . . .



Keywords & Phrases
CaseNo: C.A. No. 14,387, CourtCode: CC, CourtName: IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE, Plaintiff: GOWER, State: DE Delaware, UniqueCaseRef: DE>CC>00014387, Primavera, Beldock, Transactions, John Beldock, Settlement, Shareholders, Donald, Nammacher, Valuation, Avon, Stock, Parties, Vincent Bocchimuzzo, Stipulation, Lawson, Sales, Primavera Laboratories, Scenario, Agreement, Revenue, Reclassification, Del, Projections, Transaction, Directors, Biopharmaceutics, Certificate, Minority Shareholders, Connection, Fairness, Donald Beldock, Hall Depo, Royalties, Market, License Agreement, Reverse Stock Split, Empire Valuation, Shares, Supr, Common Stock , ContentID: 120239851

Case Documents
1 2001-07-12 STIPULATION AND AGREEMENT OF COMPROMISE SETTLEMENT AND RELEASE
[ see first page and extracted highlights below  ] ItemID: 114868
14 pages
PDF
2 2000-12-15 DEFENDANTS POST-TRIAL OPENING BRIEF
[ see first page and extracted highlights below  ] ItemID: 103415
43 pages
PDF
3 2000-10-20 DEFENDANTS PRE-TRIAL BRIEF
[ see first page and extracted highlights below  ] ItemID: 103416
33 pages
PDF
4 2000-09-29 PRE-TRIAL ORDER
[ see first page and extracted highlights below  ] ItemID: 100511
27 pages
PDF
Total Documents: 4 documents , 117 pages
Price: $ 34.95


IVESLCD01 KGI0001
 
 

 Forgot your password?


1 . STIPULATION AND AGREEMENT OF COMPROMISE SETTLEMENT AND RELEASE

EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
PLAINTIFFS
COURT
PARTIES
STIPULATION
ATTORNEYS
TRANSACTION
DEFENDANTS
RECLASSIFICATION
COUNSEL
AGREEMENT
PRIMAVERA
SHARES
CONNECTION
LAWSUIT
SETTLEMENT FUND
ADMINISTRATOR
EXPENSES
AFFILIATES
COMPROMISE
OFFICERS
REVERSE STOCK SPLIT
ESCROW ACCOUNT
PURSUANT
CLAIMANT
CLAUDE DELIBES
LABORATORIES
FINANCIAL ADVISOR
EVIDENCE
PROCEEDING
               IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE                                   
                                                                                                   
                                  lN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY                                     

____________________-----~---~---~~-------.--------~--"--   x
SAM GOWER and CLAUDE DELIBES,
                                                             ;  CA.  N o .   14387-NC
                            Plaintiffs,
         -v-                                                 1>
DONALD T. BE.LDOCK,  DR. JOHN                                                                     -.
BELDOCK, VINCENT BOCCHIMUZZO,                                i                             I .I,>
and PRIMAVERA LABORATORIES, INC., )                                                        :  -1:
                                                                                          :L. ; I,
                            Defendants.                      ;
___-________________-----~---~---"~-------~----- --_..- ",___ x

                                   STIPU:LATION  AND AGREEMENT OF                        :`:$;
                             COMPROMISE. SETTLEMENT AND RELEASE : :

         The parties to the above-captioned action, by and through their attorneys, have entered

the following Stipulation and Agreement of Compromise, Settlement and Release ("Stipulation" or

"Settlement Agreement"), subject to the approval of the Court:

WHEREAS:

         A.        On or about May 8, 1995, Donald T. Beldoclc ("Beldock"), the Chairman and Chief

Executive Officer  ofl'rimavera Laboratories, Inc. ("Primavera" or the "Company"), a developer and

licenser of personal care insect repellent products, acquired the approximately 39% of the Company

he did not already own, at a price of $11,7139  per reclassified share in cash (the "Transaction").'




          ' In connection with the transaction, the Company reclassified ,its shares by operation
l/l ,OOO,OOO reverse stock split. The $11,709 per share refers to a reclassified share. The Company,
also in connection with and in furtherance of the Transaction, cashed-out tha remaining fractional
shares after the reclassification.



        B.        Following the Transaction, certain shareholders of the Company, Sam Gower and

Claude Delibes (collectively the "Plaintiffs"), filed a class action complaint on June 20, 1995 in

SNIPPETS:
  • COMPROMISE.
  • SETTLEMENT AND RELEASE::
  • The parties to the above-captioned action, by and through their attorneys, have entered into
  • the following Stipulation and Agreement of Compromise,
  • "Settlement Agreement"), subject to the approval of the Court:
  • ' In connection with the transaction, the Company reclassified,its shares by operation of a
  • The Company, also in connection with and in furtherance of the Transaction, cashed-out tha
  • Claude Delibes, filed a class action complaint on June 20, 1995 in the
  • The .Defendants in the Lawsuit are Primavera,
  • Stipulation Regarding Class Certification dated January 15, 1999, the Court certified this
  • Plaintiffs as class representatives and designated Plaintiffs' counsel as cl.ass counsel.
  • was certified as a class action, pursuant to Rules 23and 23and on behalf of a class
  • All record and beneficial holders of Primavera Laboratories,
  • attorneys' fees and expenses totaling $175,000, the additional consideration per reclassified
  • reviewed documlents produced by Defendants and their financial advisor,
  • Plaintiffs have also considered the testimony and other evidence addnced at trial.
  • predecessors, successors, parents, subsidiaries (including the directors and officers of such
  • the escrow account yielded on those funds, less any account fees and tax withholding, if any.
  • The P,arties hereto agree that the entirety of the Settlement Fund is
  • Plaintiffs' counsel or a settlement administrator chosen by them will provide
  • the parties or administrator will notify the claimant of full or partial rejection of the
  • purpose in the Lawsuit or in any other litigation or proceeding.

  • 2 . DEFENDANTS POST-TRIAL OPENING BRIEF

    EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
    BELDOCK
    PLAINTIFFS
    TRANSACTIONS
    NAMMACHER
    VALUATION
    AVON
    JOHN BELDOCK
    DONALD
    LAWSON
    SALES
    SCENARIO
    SHAREHOLDERS
    REVENUE
    PROJECTIONS
    DEFENDANTS
    HALL DEPO
    ROYALTIES
    VINCENT BOCCHIMUZZO
    EMPIRE VALUATION
    BIOPHARMACEUTICS
    DIRECT MARKET
    LITIGATION
    MARIO AIETA
    DIRECTORS
    LICENSE AGREEMENT
    DIRECT MARKETING
    PRODUCT INTRODUCTIONS
    LABORATORIES
    EXPECTATIONS
    
                      IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
    
                                       IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
    
    
     SAM COWER and CLAUDE DeLIBES,
    
                                 Plaintiffs.
    
            V.                                                     : C.A. No. 14387  %y
                                                                                   KY
     DONALD T. BELDOCK, DR. JOHN BELDOCK,
     VINCENT BOCCHIMUZZO, and PRIMAVERA
     LABORATORIES, INC.,
    
                                Defendants.
    
    
                          DEFENDANTS' POST-TRIAL OPENING BRIEF
    
    
    
    
                                                MORRIS, NICHOLS, ARSHT & TUNNELL
                                                Alan J. Stone
                                                S Mark Hurd
                                                P.O. Box 1347
                                                Wilmington, DE 19899-1347
                                                (302) 65 8-9200
                                                 Attorneys for Defendants
    
    OF COUNSEL:
    
    Mario Aieta
    Aieta & Greco
    73 Spring St., Suite 601
    New York, New York 10012
    (212) 334-1222
    
    December  15,200O
    
    
    
                                      Q!BLE  OF CONTENTS
    
    
                                                                                                &g
    
    TABLE OF CITATIONS                                                                           ii
    
    SNIPPETS:
  • DONALD T. BELDOCK, DR. JOHN BELDOCK,
  • DEFENDANTS' POST-TRIAL OPENING BRIEF
  • Mario Aieta Aieta & Greco
  • Primavera Was Fairly Valued By Empire Valuation
  • Nammacher Based His Valuation On The Most
  • The "Attributed Value Transactions" Have No
  • Plaintiffs' Allegations Concerning "Self-Dealing"
  • SHAREHOLDERS FOR CLAIMS BASED ON ALLEGED
  • Plaintiffs commenced this action in June 1995, alleging that Primavera Laboratories, Inc.
  • Defendants Donald Beldock, John Beldock, and Vincent Bocchimuzzo are the directors
  • entered into a license agreement with Avon for the direct market (door to door sales by Avon
  • S.C. Johnson and Avon were involved in litigation over S.C.
  • Biopharmaceutics had ceased making even the minimum payments due to Primavera
  • expert, Joel Lawson, who also relied on the Discounted Cash Flow method to value Primavera, II
  • scenario, for example, assumes "that all litigation related to Primavera and its products are
  • Direct Sales Licensee outperforms i.ts general expectations for the line."
  • Nammacher's projections yield a positive terminal value when the three
  • Nammacher's revenue projections were based in part on information that he obtained
  • in charge of new product introductions" was a reliable source of information about
  • D-77 (Hall Depo.) at 15.
  • projections of sales or projections of royalties to be earned.5 III 357:13-15;
  • any of the other significant door-to-door direct marketing companies publicly disclose

  • 3 . DEFENDANTS PRE-TRIAL BRIEF

    EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
    TRANSACTIONS
    JOHN BELDOCK
    DEL
    PLAINTIFFS
    SHAREHOLDERS
    AVON
    COURT
    DONALD BELDOCK
    MARKET
    DEFENDANTS
    STOCK
    SUPR
    DELAWARE
    EMPIRE
    INSECT REPELLENT
    EPA
    LICENSE
    VINCENT BOCCHIMUZZO
    BIOPHARMACEUTICS
    TRIPLE EFFICACY
    AGREEMENT
    VALUATION
    MINORITY SHAREHOLDERS
    DIRECTORS
    TREOB
    DERIVATIVES
    EPA REGISTRATION
    DISCLOSURE
    PERSONAL CARE
    
                 IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
                           IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
    
    
    
    SAM GOWER and CLAIJDE DeLIBES,                     :: C.A. No. 14387
                       Plaintiffs,                     ::
           V.                                          :
                                                       :
    DONALD T. BELDOCK, DR. JOHN BELDOCK,               :
    VINCENT BOCCHIMUZZO, and PRIMAVERA                 :
    LABORATORIES, INC.,                                ::
                      Defendants.                      ::
    
                      @lEFENDANTS'  PRE-TRIAL BRIEF
    
    
    
    
                                            Morris, Nichols, Arsht & Tunnel1
                                            Alan J. Stone
                                            S. Mark Hurd
                                            120 1 North Market Street
                                            P.O. Box 1347
                                            Wilmington, DE 19899-1347
                                            (302) 6.58-9200
    
                                            Attorneys for Defendants
    
                                            Of counsel:
                                               Mario Aieta
                                               Aieta & Greco
                                               73 Spring St., Suite 60 1
                                               New York, New York 10012
                                               (212) 334-1222
    
    
    
                                                                                             TABLE OF
    
    HISTORY OF THE PROCEEDINGS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
     . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
    
    STATEMENT OF FACTS TO BE PROVEN AT TRIAL . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
    
                    Primavera In May 1 990 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
     . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
    
                    From June 1990 To December 1993 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
    
    SNIPPETS:
  • IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
  • The Fairness Opinion Of Empire
  • Valuation Consultants.
  • Primavera After The Transaction.
  • THE TRANSACTIONS WERE ENTIRELY FAIR
  • TO PLAINTIFFS AND TO THE CLASS.
  • DEFENDANTS DID NOT BREACH THE DUTY OF DUE CARE.
  • DR. JOHN BELDOCK AND VINCENT BOCCHIMUZZO
  • PRIMAVERA (CANNOT BE LIABLE TO ITS SHAREHOLDERS
  • Arnold v. Society For Savings Bancorp., Inc., Del.
  • Supr., 650 A.2d 1270.

  • 4 . PRE-TRIAL ORDER

    EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
    BELDOCK
    DEFENDANTS
    STOCK
    DONALD
    PLAINTIFFS
    PRIMAVERA LABORATORIES
    SHAREHOLDERS
    VINCENT BOCCHIMUZZO
    JOHN BELDOCK
    CERTIFICATE
    TRANSACTIONS
    FAIRNESS
    COURT
    PARTIES
    MINORITY SHAREHOLDERS
    AGREEMENT
    COMMON STOCK
    RECLASSIFICATION
    COMPLAINT
    DIRECTORS
    LICENSE AGREEMENT
    CONNECTION
    SPECIAL MEETING
    CHANCERY
    STIPULATED SCHEDULING ORDER
    SCHEDULING ORDER
    REVERSE STOCK
    REVERSE STOCK SPLIT
    DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT
    
                         IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
                                       IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
    -        -
         SAM GOWER and CLAUDE DIELIBES,                                C. A. No. 14387
                                          Plaintiffs,
    
                   V.
    
         PRIMAVERA LABORATORIES, INC.,
         DONALD  I:. BELDOCK, DR. JOHN BELDOCK
         and VINCENT BOCCHIMUZZO,
    
    .-                                   Defendants.
    
                                                  PM-TRIAL ORDER
    
                          Pursuant to the Stipulated Scheduling Order, the parties hereby submit this
    
         Order.
    
                                             NATURE OF THE ACTION
    
                          This is a class akction  suit brought by minority shareholders challenging
    
         fairness of a reclassification, reverse stock split of Primavera Inc. ("Primavera" or the
    
         and cash out of the remaining fractional share interests. This action was filed in June, 1995.
    
         Defendants filed an answer to the Complaint in August, 1995. Plaintiffs moved for class
    
         certification on March 24, 1998. Defendants stipulated to class certification, and on January
    
         1999 the Court granted plaintiffs motion for class certification. The Class is defined as: all
    
         and beneficial holders of Primavera Laboratories, Inc. common stock as of May 8, 1995 and their
    
         successors in interest, transferees and assigns, immediate and remote (excluding defendants
    
         person, firm, trust, corporation or other entity related to or affiliated with any of the
    
         "Class"), Pursuant to a revised scheduling order agreed to by the parties and entered by the
    
    
    
    dated February 2,2000, a pre-trial conference is set for October 2,200O  at 2:00 p.m. and trial is
    
    for the week of October 23,200O. The parties have not moved for summary judgment.
    
          FACTS AND LAW ARE! WHICH ARE ADMITTED AND REOUIRE NO PROOF
    
    SNIPPETS:
  • IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
  • PRIMAVERA LABORATORIES, INC., DONALD I:. BELDOCK, DR. JOHN BELDOCK
  • Pursuant to the Stipulated Scheduling Order, the parties hereby submit this Pre-Trial
  • This is a class akction suit brought by minority shareholders challenging the entire
  • fairness of a reclassification, reverse stock split of Primavera Inc.
  • Defendants filed an answer to the Complaint in August,
  • 1999 the Court granted plaintiffs motion for class certification.
  • and beneficial holders of Primavera Laboratories, Inc. common stock as of May 8, 1995 and
  • Pursuant to a revised scheduling order agreed to by the parties and entered by the Court
  • In March, 1994, Primavera's Board of Directors approved a 10 year
  • J. Beldock entered into a ten year consuhing agreement with the Company
  • Vincent Bocchimuzzo became a director ofPrimaverano later than
  • to the Company's Certificate of Incorporation to reclassify each share of Primavera common
  • of shares the Company is authorized to issue from 50,000,OOO to 50 shares ("reverse stock
  • Certificate of Incorporation.
  • Incorporation to effectuate the Transactions.
  • render an opinion on the fairness from a financial point of view to Primavera's shareholders
  • In connection with the Empire Report, Empire prepared, a series of Primaverarevenue
  • benefited frforn the financial impact of the Avon license agreement.
  • Primavera was founded by defendants Donald T. Beldock and Dr. John Beldock to develop
  • Minutes Of Special Meeting Of Board Of Directors Of Primavera 0208-02 12
  • Deposition Transcript of Vincent Bocchimuzzo
  •    |