LegalCaseDocs.com
shopping cart  
  |     
Search
 

 
New Visitors


 VeriSign Secure Site

 Get Adobe Reader

JACKSON NATIONAL LIFE INSURANCE v KENNEDY Click to find out why . . .



Keywords & Phrases
CaseNo: C.A. No. 16,472, CourtCode: CC, CourtName: IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY FOR THE STATE OF DELAWARE, Plaintiff: JACKSON NATIONAL LIFE INSURANCE, State: DE Delaware, UniqueCaseRef: DE>CC>00016472, Benchmark Holdings, Wincup Holdings, Radnor Parties, James, Kennedy, James River, Allegations, Stockholders, Complaint, Radnor Parties Admit, Preferred Stockholders, Benchmark Corporation, Wincup Partnership, James River Paper, Fort James, Fiduciary Duty, Paragraph, Assets, Delaware, Transaction, First Amended Complaint, Loyalty, Directors, Sole, Respectfully Refer, Fort James Operating, Disclosure, Certificate, Affirmatively Aver, Del, Information Sufficient, Winkler/flexible Products , ContentID: 120239782

Case Documents
1 1999-08-31 ANSWER TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT
[ see first page and extracted highlights below  ] ItemID: 102137
33 pages
PDF
2 1999-07-15 MEMORANDUM OPINION
[ see first page and extracted highlights below  ] ItemID: 100379
30 pages
PDF
3 1998-08-31 OPENING BRIEF OF FORT JAMES CORP AND FORT JAMES OPERATING CO. IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS
[ see first page and extracted highlights below  ] ItemID: 103692
4 pages
PDF
Total Documents: 3 documents , 67 pages
Price: $ 29.95


IVESLCD01 KGI0001
 
 

 Forgot your password?


1 . ANSWER TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT

EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
WINCUP HOLDINGS
BENCHMARK HOLDINGS
JAMES RIVER
ALLEGATIONS
COMPLAINT
RADNOR PARTIES ADMIT
BENCHMARK CORPORATION
JAMES RIVER PAPER
WINCUP PARTNERSHIP
DEFENDANTS
COURT
PARAGRAPH
KENNEDY
PLAINTIFFS
ASSETS
FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT
FORT JAMES
RESPECTFULLY REFER
FORT JAMES OPERATING
AFFIRMATIVELY AVER
INFORMATION SUFFICIENT
WINKLER/FLEXIBLE PRODUCTS
PARTIES LACK KNOWLEDGE
RADNOR PARTIES LACK
THERMOFORM
LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
PLASTIC CUTLERY
SUBPARAGRAPH
F/K/A BENCHMARK CORPORATION
      IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY FOR THE STATE OF DELAWARE

                       IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY


JACKSON NATIONAL LIFE
INSURANCE COMPANY and
BENCHMARK HOLDINGS, INC.,

              Plaintiffs,

       V .                                             Civil Action No. 16472NC

MICHAEL T. KENNEDY, RADNOR
HOLDINGS CORPORATION, successor to
Benchmark Corporation of Delaware,
WINCUP HOLDINGS, INC., WINCUP
HOLDINGS, L.P., FORT JAMES
CORPORATION, successor to James River
Corporation of Virginia, and
FORT JAMES OPERATING COMPANY,
INC., successor to James River Paper
Company, Inc.,

              Defendants.

                  ANSWER TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT

               Defendants, Michael T. Kennedy ("Kennedy"), Radnor Holdings

Corporation, f/k/a Benchmark Corporation of Delaware: ("Radnor" or "Benchmark

Corporation"), WinCup Holdings, Inc. ("WinCup  Holdings"), and WinCup Hold-

ings, L.P. (the "WinCup Partnership," and collectively, the "Radnor Parties"), by

their attorneys, Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom., LLP, respond as follows to

the allegations of the First Amended Complaint (the "Complaint"):



               1.      Denied.

               2.      Denied, except the Radnor Parties admit that Plaintiffs purport

to bring this action against Kennedy, Radnor, WinCup Holdings, WinCup Partner-

ship, Fort James Corporation ("Fort James"), and Fort James Operating Company,
SNIPPETS:
  • IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY FOR THE STATE OF DELAWARE
  • MICHAEL T. KENNEDY, RADNOR
  • HOLDINGS CORPORATION, successor to Benchmark Corporation of Delaware,
  • FORT JAMES OPERATING COMPANY,
  • INC., successor to James River Paper Company, Inc.,
  • ANSWER TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT
  • Defendants, Michael T. Kennedy, Radnor Holdings
  • f/k/a Benchmark Corporation of Delaware:
  • Corporation"), WinCup Holdings, Inc., and WinCup Holdings, L.P., by
  • except the Radnor Parties admit that Plaintiffs purport
  • to bring this action against Kennedy, Radnor, WinCup Holdings, WinCup Partnership, Fort James
  • Holdings, Inc. ("Benchmark Holdings"), and Benchmark Holdings, and deny
  • Corporation"), or between Fort James Operating and James River Paper Company,
  • and therefore deny those allegations.
  • Paragraph 5 of the Complaint contains legal conclusions as to
  • The Radnor Parties lack knowledge or information sufficient
  • Benchmark Holdings sold certain assets to James River Paper on or about
  • and respectfully refer the Court to the Certificate of Designation for its
  • affirmatively aver that Kennedy resigned as president and director of Benchmark
  • Denied, except the Radnor Parties admit that WinCup Partnership was at one time a Delaware
  • Holdings' plastic cutlery and drinking straws assets and WinCup Holdings'
  • thermoform assets; on or about January 20, 1996, James River Paper contributed its
  • collateral (the assets of Winkler/Flexible Products).
  • The Radnor Parties admit in response to subparagraph that, pursuant to the transaction which

  • 2 . MEMORANDUM OPINION

    EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
    JAMES
    KENNEDY
    STOCKHOLDERS
    WINCUP HOLDINGS
    PLAINTIFFS
    PREFERRED STOCKHOLDERS
    FORT JAMES
    FIDUCIARY DUTY
    DELAWARE
    DEFENDANTS
    TRANSACTION
    LOYALTY
    DIRECTORS
    ASSETS
    SOLE
    DISCLOSURE
    CERTIFICATE
    FIDUCIARY DUTIES
    WINCUP PARTNERSHIP
    COMPLAINT ALLEGES
    VOTING EVENT
    PREFERRED STOCK
    COMMUNICATIONS
    PARTICIPATION
    OBLIGATION
    UNJUST ENRICHMENT
    JAMES RIVER
    WILMINGTON
    ALLEGATIONS
    
          IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY FOR THE STATE OF DELAWARE                                " '
                           IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
    
    JACKSON NATIONAL LIFE                           >
    INSURANCE COMPANY and                           >
    BENCHMARK HOLDINGS, INC.,  )
    
                   Plaintiffs,
    
    V.                                              ) C.A. N-o. 16472
    
    MICHAEL T. KENNEDY, RADNOR)
    HOLDINGS CORPORATION,                           >
    successor to Benchmark Corporation )
    of Delaware, WINCUP  HOLDINGS, )
    INC., WINCUP HOLDINGS, L.P.,                    )
    FORT JAMES CORPORATION,                         )
    successor to James River Corporation )
    of Virginia, and FORT JAMES                     >
    OPERATING COMPANY, INC.,                        )
    successor to James River Paper                  >
    Company, Inc.,                                  >
    
                   Defendants.                      >
    
                                  Submitted: February 26, 1999
                                      Decided: July 15, 1999
    
                                  MEMUR4NDUM  OPINION
    
    Jay W. Eisenhofer and Cynthia A. Calder of Grant & Eisenhofer, Wilmington, Delaware. OF
    COUNSEL: William I. Goldberg, J. Michael Williams, and Judith M. Hudson of Holleb & Coff,
    Chicago, Illinois. Attorneys for Plaintiffs.
    
    P.  Clarkson Collins, Jr. and Joseph C.  Schoell of Morris, James,  Hitchens  & Williams,
    Wilmington, Delaware. OF COUNSEL: James H. Walsh and H. Carter Redd of  McGuire,
    Woods, Battle & Boothe, Richmond, Virginia. Attorneys for Defendants.
    
    STEELE, V.C.
    
    
    
                               I. ISSUES PRESENTED
    
          Benchmark Holdings Inc. ("Benchmark Holdings") and Jackson National
    
    Life Insurance Co. ("Jackson National"), a preferred stockholder of Benchmark
    
    Holdings, brought an action against the former president and sole director of
    
    SNIPPETS:
  • MICHAEL T. KENNEDY, RADNOR)
  • successor to Benchmark Corporation) of Delaware, WINCUP HOLDINGS,)
  • successor to James River Corporation)
  • Jay W. Eisenhofer and Cynthia A. Calder of Grant & Eisenhofer, Wilmington, Delaware.
  • Attorneys for Plaintiffs.
  • Benchmark Holdings Inc. and Jackson National
  • associated with the acquisition of Benchmark Holdings' assets by Fort James
  • and abetting Kennedy in his alleged breaches of fiduciary duty,
  • this motion raises the issue of whether the complaint alleges
  • disclosure to the preferred stockholders; in the event that Kennedy owed those
  • fiduciary duties, that he breached them; and that Fort James knowingly
  • Designation (the "Certificate") when Kennedy intentionally omitted material facts
  • intentionally false and misleading communications to Jackson National's
  • for breach of a fiduciary duty of loyalty.
  • Holdings' sole director, that Kennedy unfairly allocated the proceeds from the sale
  • transaction in this action, Defendant Kennedy owned approximately 90 percent
  • James Corp. is the successor to James River Corp. of Virginia,
  • cup and container businesses to the WinCup Partnership.
  • I Benchmark Holdings issued 3,800,OOO shares of Series A Convertible Preferred Stock, of
  • provides that the Benchmark Holdings board of directors "does hereby fix and
  • Certificate provides that the preferred stockholders could appoint a majority of the
  • By agreement between Jackson National and Green Capital, in the case of such a Voting Event,
  • Plaintiffs contend that Defendants essentially exchanged Benchmark
  • In addition to the allegations that Jackson National had no foreknowledge
  • duty and unjust enrichment counts brought against it pursuant to Court
  • fiduciary obligation has been characterized by the Supreme Court as a "triad":
  • Non-Fiduciary's Knowing Participation in the Breaches

  • 3 . OPENING BRIEF OF FORT JAMES CORP AND FORT JAMES OPERATING CO. IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS

    EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
    JAMES
    CHANDLER
    SUPR
    FORT JAMES
    LITIGATION
    PARTNERS
    STEELE
    VIRGINIA
    OPERATING
    TRUST
    RICHMOND
    AUTHORITIES
    NATURE
    PROCEEDING
    INTRODUCTORY STATEMENT
    FACTS
    CONSTRUCTIVE TRUST
    FAIL
    BERNSTEIN
    CANET
    BOUSH
    HODGES
    AFFD
    BROOK
    ACME STEEL
    DODGE
    WILMINGTON TRUST
    GALE
    BERSHAD
    
             IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE. OF DELAWARE
                           IN AND FORNEW CASTLE COUNTY
    
    JACKSON NATIONAL LIFE                      >
    INSURANCE COMPANY and                      >
    BENCHMARK HOLDINGS, INC.,                  >>
                         Plaintiffs,           >
    V.                                                 Civil Action No. 16472-NC         -
                                                                                    .
                                               1
    MICHAEL T. KENNEDY,                        >                                                       
    RADNOR HOLDINGS CORPORATION,  )                                                                    
    successor to Benchmark Corporation of      )                                              _
    Delaware,  WINCUP HOLDINGS, INC.,          )
    WINCUP HOLDINGS, L.P.,                     >                                                   .-
    FORT JAMES CORPORATION,                    >                                                   .
                                                                                              I.       
    
    
    successor to James River Corporation of )                                                          
    Virginia, and FORT JAMES OPERATING )
    COMPANY, INC., successor to James          )
    River Paper Company, Inc.,
                                               ;
                         Defendants.           )
    
          OPENING BRIEF OF FORT JAMES CORPORATION AND FORT JAMES
           OPERATING COMPANY, INC. IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION TO
                         DISMISS PURSUANT TO RULE  12(b)(6)
    
                                        MORRIS, JAMES, HITCHENS & WILLIAMS
                                        P. Clarkson Collins, Jr.
                                        Joseph C. Schoell
                                        222 Delaware Avenue
                                        Wilmington, DE 1980 1
                                        (302) 888-6800
                                        Attorneys for Defendants Fort James Corporation
                                        and Fort James Operating Co., Inc.
    OF COUNSEL:
    McGUIRE, WOODS, BATTLE & BOOTHE LLP
    James H. Walsh
    H. Carter Redd
    One James Center, 901 East Car-y Street
    Richmond, Virginia 232 19
    (804) 775-1000
    August 3 1, 1998
    
    
    
    
    SNIPPETS:
  • Virginia, and FORT JAMES OPERATING)
  • OPENING BRIEF OF FORT JAMES CORPORATION AND FORT JAMES OPERATING COMPANY,
  • Richmond, Virginia 232 19
  • TABLE OF AUTHORITIES.
  • STATEMENT OF THE NATURE AND STAGE OF THE PROCEEDING.
  • INTRODUCTORY STATEMENT
  • STATEMENT OF FACTS.
  • Constructive Trust Must Fail.
  • Bernstein v. Canet, Del.
  • No. 13924, Chandler, V.C..
  • Boush v. Hodges, Del.
  • No. 12916, Allen, C., affd, Del.
  • Brook v. Acme Steel Co.,
  • Dodge v. Wilmington Trust Co.,
  • Gale v. Bershad, Del.
  • Supr., 539 A.2d 180.
  • In re Shoe-Town Inc. Stockholders Litigation,
  • No. 13206, Steele, V.C..
  • Vanderbilt Income & Growth Associates, L.L.C. v. Arvida/JMB Partners, Del.
  •    |