 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| | | |
|
|
|
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
1
.
MEMORANDUM OPINION
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
WOLF COURT TIKELLIS CHIMICLES YORK PLAINTIFFS COUNSEL SETTLEMENT DEFENDANTS WOLF HALDENSTEIN LITIGATION SANDERS FEES LLP ALLOCATION WOLF HALDERSTEIN GARWIN BRONZAFT SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT SUBSTANTIATE SHAREHOLDERS BILLING RECORDS SETTLEMENT NEGOTIATIONS WILMINGTON PROPOSED ALLOCATION SUCCESSFUL INVOLVEMENT FRED TAYLOR ISQUITH WOLF HALDENSTEIN ADLER HALDENSTEIN ADLER FREEMAN |
ORIGINAL ,a&
IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
LISA SANDERS,
Plaintiff,
v.
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR,
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. deVOGEL,
RICHARD A. GRASSO, IRVING GOLDSTEIN,
and SHIRLEY STRUM KENNY,
Defendants,
and
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL
INC.,
Nominal Defendant.
EDWARD BICKEL, derivatively on behalf of
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL
INC.,
Plaintiff,
V.
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR,
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. deVOGEL,
IRVlNG GOLSTEIN, and RICHARD A. GRASSO,
Defendants,
and
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES
INTERNATIONAL, INC.,
Nominal Defendant.
Submitted: August 20, 200 1
Decided: September 18, 2001
SNIPPETS:
|
|
2
.
LETTER OPINION
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
COURT REQUEST MISREPRESENTATION SETTLEMENT RESPONSE KNOWING MISREPRESENTATION DEADLINE SANDERS WANG PAPERS TACTICAL ADVANTAGE FEES MATERIAL FACT MISSTATEMENT MONHAIT ALLEGATION LITIGATION EXPENSES REMEDY SANCTIONS PROCEEDING WILMINGTON COUNSEL REMARKS SETTLEMENT DOCUMENTS TEXAS REQUEST ASKING AWAIT OUTSTANDING |
SUPREME COURT OF DELAWARE
M Y R O N T. S T E E L E S U P R E M E
JUSTICE 57
P.O.
D O V E R ,
TELEPHONE:
Norman M. Monhait Alan J. Stone
Rosenthal, Monhait, Gross Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunnel1
& Goddess 120 1 N. Market Street
P.O. Box 1070 Wilmington, DE 19899
Wilmington, DE 19899- 1070
Gregory V. Varallo
Grover C. Brown Richards Layton & Finger
Gordon Fournaris & Mammarella One Rodney Square
1220 Market Street, Suite 700 Wilmington, DE 1980 1
Wilmington, DE 19899
Daniel W. Krasner
Pamela S. Tikellis Wolf Haldenstein Adler
Chimicles & Tikellis Freeman & Her-z LLP
One Rodney Square 270 Madison Avenue
Wilmington, DE 1980 1 New York, NY 100 16
James L. Holzman Harvey Greenfield
Prickett Jones & Elliott Suite 2001
13 10 N. King Street 60 East 42qd Street
Wilmington, DE 19899 New York, NY 10165
Re: Sanders v. Wang and Bickel v. Wang
Del. Ch., Civil Action No. 16640-NC
Submitted: August 20,200l
Decided: August 22,200l
Sanders v. Wang (I 6640-NC)
August 22,200l
Page 2
Counsel:
The Court scheduled a settlement hearing in this case for November 9,200O.
At that hearing, Mr. Greenfield suggested by certain remarks that he had not been
SNIPPETS:
|
|
3
.
LETTER OPINION
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
ATTORNEYS COURT SANDERS GREENFIELD SETTLEMENT DISTRICT WANG LITIGATION STOCK COUNSEL PLAINTIFFS SHAREHOLDERS COMPLAINT SUITS COMPENSATION EASTERN DISTRICT YORK DELAWARE COMMITTEE CHANCERY SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AWARD OPINION JERRY KRIM DIRECTORS SHARES DEL KESOP PERMIT |
:
SUPREME COURT OF DELAWARE
M YRON T. STEELE SUPREME C
J U S T I C E 57 T
DOVER, D
TELEPHONE:
Nor-n-ran M. Monhait Alan J. Stone
Rosenthal, Monhait, Gross Morris Nichols Arsht & Tunne!l
& Goddess 1201 N. Market Street
P.O. Box 1070 Wilmington, DE 19899
Wilmington, DE 19899- 1070
Gregory V. Varallo
Grover C. Brown Richards Layton & Finger
Gordon Fournaris & Mammarella One Rodney Square
1220 Market Street, Suite 700 Wilmington, DE 1980 1
Wilmington, DE 19899
Daniel W. Krasner
Pamela S. Tikellis Wolf Waldenstein Adler Freeman
Chimicles & Tikellis & Herz LLP
One Rodney Square 270 Madison Avenue
Wilmington, DE 1980 1 New York, NY 100 16
James L. Holzman Harvey Greenfield
Prickett Jones & Elliott Suite 200 I
13 10 N. King Street 60 East 42nd Street
Wilmington, DE 19899 New York, NY 10 165
Re: Sanders v. N/arrg and Bickel v. Wang
Del. Ch., Civil Action No. 16640-NC
Submitted: November 28,200O
Decided: May 24,200l
SNIPPETS:
|
|
4
.
REPLY MEMORANDUM OF BLANK ROME AND GARWIN BRONZAFT IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF ALLOCATION OF ATTORNEYS FEES
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
ALLOCATION GARWIN BRONZAFT CONTRACT CLAIM ROME FEE OBJECTION SETTLEMENT SUPPORT DELAWARE ACTION MOTION COMPLAINT OPENING ALLOCATION INTERVENTION COURT WOLF HALDENSTEIN YORK ACTION DEFENDANTS ATTORNEYS PLAINTIFFS INVOLVEMENT ALLEGED FRAUD NEGOTIATIONS AFFIDAVIT JOINT OBJECTORS ARGUE STOCK PRICE GREENFIELD DERIVATIVE ACTION KESOP MEMORANDUM |
IN THE COURT OF CHANCEfRY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE /4 I
IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
LISA SANDERS,
Plaintiff,
V. i
>
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY K.UMAR, RUSSELL
M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. de VOGEL, RICHARD i
A. GRASSO, IRVING GOLDSTEIN, and SHIRLEY > CA. No. 16640
STRlJM KENNY,
i
Defendants,
and
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC., )
Nominal Defendant. i
_________1______1_____I_________________---------------------------"-
EDWARD BICKEL, derivatively on behalf of i
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC., )
Plaintiff,
V. >
1
CHA.RL,ES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, RUSSELL )
M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. de VOGEL, IRVING
GOL.DSTEIN, and RICHARD A. GRASSO,
Defendants,
and
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC. )
>
Nominal Dekndant.
REPLY MEMORANDUM OF BLANK ROME AND GARWIN BRONZAFT
IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF THEIR ALLOCATLON OF ATTORNEYS' FEES
AND IN FURTHER RESPONSE TO OBJECTIONS TO THE ALLOCATION
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SNIPPETS:
|
|
5
.
MEMORANDUM IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF JOINT OBJECTION TO PROPOSED ALLOCATION OF ATTORNEYS FEES
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
FEES DERIVATIVE ACTION ALLOCATION YORK LITIGATION DELAWARE GARWIN BRONZAFT JOINT OBJECTION ATTORNEYS FAIR ALLOCATION EASTERN DISTRICT PLAINTIFFS DEFENDANTS COUNSEL BICKEL SETTLEMENT WOLF HALDENSTEIN WOLFKHIMICLES COMPLAINT ULTIMATELY SUCCESSFUL INTERVENTION WOLF/CHIMICLES CHIMICLES AFFIDAVIT WOLFICHIMICLES WOLFCHIMICLES CONSOLIDATION KRASNER AFF STIPULATION |
$N THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE. OF DELAWAkk ii u 1 ;:.`$A,e,;
IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
___________I______._______________I_____---~-~~-------------~-------~-
LISA SANDERS, ,'
Plaintiff,
V. ; C.A. No. 16640
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KIJMAR, i
RUSSEILL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. deVOGEL,
RICHARD A. GRASSO, IRVING GOLDSTEIN, ,'
and SHIRLEY STRUM KENNY,
,'
Defendants,
and i)
COMPIJTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC.,)
Nominal Defendant. ; MEMORANDUM IN FURTHER
_________~_________________________I___----~----------------------"- > SUPPORT OF JOINT OBJECTION
EDWARD BICKEL, derivatively on behalf of > TO THE PROPOSED
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC.,) OF ATTORNEYS' FEES BY. BLANK
ROME AND GARWIN
Plaintiff, i
V.
i
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, RUSSEL )
M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. de VOGEL, IRVING
GOLDSTEIN, and RICHARD A. GRASSO, ;
Defendants, i
and
i
COMPUTER. ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC. )1
Nominal Defendant.
;
____________________--------------~.----~.----------------"-----"-"-- 1 CA. No. 98 CV
UNITECD STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK ;
_______________________I________________I_______------,.--~-------.~-- 1
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC. )
DERIVATIVE LITIGATION
_______________~_______________________---~-------------------------
TA-BLE OF CONTENTS
SNIPPETS:
|
|
6
.
REPLY TO MEMORANDUM IN OPPOSITION TO OBJECTIONS TO ALLOCATION OF PLAINTIFFS COUNSELS FEES
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
COURT COMPLAINT YORK FEES COUNSEL SETTLEMENT MONHAIT WOLF HALDENSTEIN DELAWARE FIRM ALLOCATION PLAINTIFFS LAW LITIGATION HARVEY GREENFIELD MONHAIT MEMO EXHIBIT TIME RECORDS ALLEGATIONS MEMORANDUM REQUESTS SUPPORT DISCOVERY CO-LEAD COUNSEL HERETO COPY-CAT COMPLAINT CLIENT STIPULATION GERSTEIN |
IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE: OF DELAWARE
JN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
LISA SANDERS,
Plaintiff,
V.
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, RUSSELL ) Civil Action No.
M. ARTZT, WILL,EM F.P. de VOGEL, RICHARD )
A. GRASSO, IRVING GOLDSTEIN, and SHIRLEY )
STRUM KENNY, >
Defendants, ;
and ;>
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC., )
I
Nominal Defendant. i
___________~_______----~.----------------------------------------------- >
EDWARD BICKEL, derivatively on behalf of )
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC., )
>
Plaintiff,
i
V.
;
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, RUSSELL )
M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. de VOGEL, IRVING
GOLDSTEIN, and RICHARD A. GRASSO, t
Defendants, i
and ;>
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC., ))
Nominal Defendant.
-____________-___-----~_-----------------------------------------------
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
______________-_________________________--------------"---------------- >
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC. ) Civil Action No.
DERIVATIVE LITIGATION > 98 CV 4961 (TCP)
SNIPPETS:
|
|
7
.
JOINT OBJECTION TO THE PROPOSED ALLOCATOIN OF ATTORNEYS FEES
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
GARWIN BRONZAFT COURT SETTLEMENT ROME FEES YORK SHARES SANDERS ALLOCATION WOLF HALDENSTEIN DISTRICT JUDGEMENT ATTORNEYS LAW FIRMS DEFENDANTS LITIGATION CONNECTION KRASNER AFF PROSECUTION COMMON STOCK LLP FEDERAL PROCEEDINGS JUDGE PLATT EASTERN DISTRICT CONSOLIDATION AFFIDAVITS GREENFIELD SUBSTANTIALL |
207197
IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
LISA SANDERS,
Plaintiff,
V.
ii
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, RUSSELL ) Civil Action No. 16640
) Civil Action No. 16640 J
M ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. deVOGEL, RICHARD A. 11
GRASSO, IRVING GOLDSTEIN, and SHIRLEY 11
STRUM KENNY,
Defendants,
COMPUT:ER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC.,
Nominal Defendant. ; JOINT OBJECTION TO THE
___________-_____--_________I___________----------------------------- ) PROPOSED ALLOCATION OF
EDWARD BICKEL, derivatively on behalf of ) ATTORNEYS' FEES BY BLANK
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC., ) ROME AND GARWIN BRONZAFT
1
Plaintiff,
i
V.
j'
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, RUSSEL M. )
ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. de VOGEL, IRVING
GOLDSTEIN, and RICHARD A. GRASSO, ;
Defendants, i
and i1
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC. )
Nominal Defendant. i) Civil Actl.on No. 98 CV
___--____---____---_------------------------~-------------~----------
b-NITED STATES DISTRICT COURT i
SNIPPETS:
|
|
8
.
RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO MEMORANDUM REGARDING ALLOCATION OF FEES
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
COUNSEL FEE COURT PLAINTIFFS ALLOCATION COMPLAINT FIRM DELAWARE PLAINTIFFS DISTRICT COURT REQUEST MEMORANDUM GERSTEIN UNGER YORK HARVEY GREENFIELD SETTLEMENT LITIGATION ASSERTION MAGISTRATE JERRY KRIM HERETO MORRIS DISMISSING DEFAMATORY EXPENSES AFFIDAVIT AWARD CONFER INFORMED GREENFIELD |
IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELA
IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
LISA SANDERS,
Plaintiff,
;
V.
;
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, RUSSELL ) Civil Action No.
M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. (de VOGEL, RICHARD )
A. GRASSO, IRVING GOLl>STEIN, and SHIRLEY )
STRUM KENNY >
;
Defendants,
;
and ))
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC., )
Nominal Defendant I ;
_______________-____-----~.-------~-___________________________________
EDWARD BICKEL, derivatkely on behalf of ;
COMPUTER ASSOCIATE3 INTERNATIONAL, INC., )
Plaintiff, i)
V.
;
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, RUSSELL )
M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. de VOGEL, IRVING
GOLDSTEIN, and RICHAF!D A. GRASSO, i
>
Defendants,
;
and
;
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC., ))
Nominal Defendant.
________________-___------------~~--------------------------~~.-------- i
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
___________-________-----~-------.~________-_____________----~~.-------- >
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC. ) Civil Action No.
DERIVATIVE LITIGATION 98 CV 4961 (TCP)
___-_-______________-----~___-___._~_-___________________----~~.--------
RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO MEMORANDUM
REGARDING ALLOCATION OF FEES, AND MOTION FOR
SNIPPETS:
|
|
9
.
ORDER AND FINAL JUDGMENT
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
SETTLEMENT SHAREHOLDERS COURT DERIVATIVE ACTION DIRECTORS AFFILIATES ATTORNEYS HEREBY ADMINISTRATORS PLAINTIFFS HEIRS SUCCESSORS BANKERS JUDGEMENT LAW DEFENDANTS PARTIES REPRESENTATIVES ASSERTION DISMISSES EXECUTORS OFFICERS SCHEDULING PROVIDERS PREJUDICE PARENTS SUBSIDIARIES LIMITED PARTNERS SHARES |
IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
IN A.ND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY "' _ ,-`.\
I,
c-y; .::
_-
X
LISA SANDERS, 2:. `-.
i
-_
- ,'
Plaintiff,
V.
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, RUSSEL M. :
ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. de VOGEL, RICHARD A. :
GRASSO, IRVING GOLDSTEIN, and SHIRLEY :
STRUM KENNY,
Defendant,
: CA No. 16640
and
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC., i
Nominal
Defendant.
X
EDWARD BICKEL, derivatively on behalf of
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC., :
Plaintiff,
v.
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJ.AY KUMAR, RUSSEL M. :
ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. de VOGEL, IRVING
GOLDSTEIN and RICHARD A. GRASSO,
Defendants,
and
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, INC., :
Nominal Defendant.
X
SNIPPETS:
|
|
10
.
PLAINTIFFS BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF PROPOSED SETTLEMENT AWARD OF ATTORNEYS FEES AND REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
FEES SETTLEMENT COURT DEFENDANTS YORK DELAWARE BICKEL AWARD ATTORNEYS EXPENSES DERIVATIVE ACTIONS SANDERS DEL SANJAY KUMAR WANG NOMINAL DEFENDANT EDWARD BICKEL IRVING GOLDSTEIN SHAREHOLDERS LITIG PROPOSED SETTLEMENT LLP LITIGATION KESOP LISA SANDERS STOCK DIVIDENDS CLASS ACTIONS DIRECTORS REIMBURSEMENT WILMINGTON |
IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
-------------------------------------------------------------~
LISA SANDERS,
Plaintiff,
: Civil Action No. 16640
V.
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, :
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P.
de VOGEL, RICHARD A. GRASSO,
IRVING GOLDSTEIN and SHIRLEY STRUM I
KENNY,
Defendants,
-and-
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, 1
INC.,
Nominal Defendant. :
-------------------------------------------------------------~
EDWARD BICKEL, derivatively on
behalf of COMPUTER ASSOCIATES
INTERNATIONAL, INC.,
Plaintiff,
V.
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR,
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P.
DE VOGEL, IRVING GOLDSTEIN, and
RICHARD A. GRASSO,
Defendants,
-and-
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, :
INC.,
Nominal Defendant, :
-------------------------------------------------------------~
PLAINTIFFS' BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF THE PROPOSED SETTLEMENT,
AWARD OF ATTORNEYS' FEES AND REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES
ROSENTHAL, MONHAlT, GROSS & GODDESS, P.A.
Norman M. Monhait
SNIPPETS:
|
|
11
.
ORDER
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
DEFENDANTS DISPUTED SHARES COURT CERTIFICATES PLAINTIFF JUDGEMENT PURSUANT CANCELLING DELAWARE MOTION PLEADINGS KESOP WANG KUMAR ARTZT SUPREME COURT APPEALS VOID SANDERS DISMISS OPINION PARAGRAPH CERTIFICATES EVIDENCING DIRECTING ISSUANCE SUCCESSOR RUSSELL STOCK DESTRUCTION |
IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
-----------------------------------------------------------------------~---~
LISA SANDERS,
Plaintiff,
V. : Civil Action No. 16640
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR., :
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P.
de VOGEL, RICHARD A. GRASSO,
IRVING GOLDSTEIN and SHIRLEY STRUM I
KENNY,
Defendants.
and
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL :
INC.,
Nominal Defendant. :
----------------------------------------------------~---------~
EDWARD BICKEL, derivatively on
behalf of COMPUTER ASSOCIATES
INTERNATIONAL, INC.,
Plaintiff,
V .
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KT_JMAR, :
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P.
de VOGEL, IRVING GOLDSTEIN
and RICHARD A. GRASSO,
Defendants.
and
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL :
INC.,
Nominal Defendant. :
!3RDER
SNIPPETS:
|
|
12
.
MEMORANDUM OPINION
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
DEFENDANTS SHARES PLAN COURT YORK SHAREHOLDERS GRANT DELAWARE STOCK PROVISION SANDERS CONTRACT AWARD DIRECTORS JUDGEMENT KESOP INTERPRETATION AUTHORITY AUTHORIZE CONSTRUCTIVE TRUST STOCK SPLITS PLEADINGS WILMINGTON ATTORNEYS FIDUCIARY DUTY COMPENSATION COMMITTEE EXCESS SHARES LISA SANDERS MEMORANDUM OPINION |
IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
LISA SANDERS,
Plaintiff,
V.
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR,
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P.
de VOGEL, RICHARD A. GRASSO,
IRVING GOLDSTEIN and SHIRLEY >
STRUM KENNY, >>
Defendants, )>
and ) C.A. No. 16640
>
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES >
INTERNATIONAL, INC.,
Nominal Defendant. >
__-___----------__------------------------------------
EDWARD BICKEL, derivatively on >
behalf of COMPUTER ASSOCIATES >
INTERNATIONAL, INC., >>
Plaintiff, 1>
V. >>
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, >
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. >
de VOGEL, IRVING GOLDSTEIN, and >
RICHARD A. GRASSO, 1>
Defendants, 1>
and >>
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES >
INTERNATIONAL, INC., >>
Nominal Defendant. >
Submitted: August 4, 1999
Decided: November 8, 1999
MEMORANDUM OPINION
Pamela S. Tikellis, James C. Strum and Robert J. Kriner of Chimicles & Tikellis,
Wilmington, DE 19899. OF COUNSEL: Scott Fisher of Garwin, Bonzaft,
Gerstein & Fisher, New York, New York. Attorneys for Plaintiff Edward Bickel.
Norman M. Monhait of Rosenthal, Monhait, Gross & Goddess, Wilmington,
SNIPPETS:
|
|
13
.
SANDERS REPLY BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
PLAN PLAIN LANGUAGE ARTZT INTERPRETATION STOCK YORK SHARES PRICE PLAINTIFF LISA SANDERS STOCKHOLDERS SHAREHOLDERS VESTING PRICE AWARD DEFENDANTS WANG KUMAR AUTHORIZES COMMON STOCK PROVISION PROXY STATEMENT DIRECTORS WILMINGTON DELAWARE TENZER GREENBLATT LLP CHRYSLER BUILDING GEORGE LINCK ATTORNEYS STRAINED INTERPRETATION |
IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE /o
IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY Ip0
__-_--_-_---------_----.-----~----- X
LISA SANDERS, :
:
Plaintiff, Civil Action No. 16640
V .
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, :
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. :
de VOGEL, RICHARD A. GRASSO,
IRVING GOLDSTEIN and SHIRLEY STRUM
KENNY, Defendants, :
:
-and- :
:
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, :
INC.,
Nominal Defendant. :
--------------------------------------x PLAINTIFF SANDERS'
REPLY BRIEF
EDWARD BICKEL, derivatively on IN SUPPORT OF HER
behalf of COMPUTER ASSOCIATES MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON
INTERNATIONAL, INC., : THE PLEADINGS AND IN
OPPOSITION TO
Plaintiff, : DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR
JUDGMENT ON THE
V . PLEADINGS AND TO DISMISS
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, :
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P.
DE VOGEL, IRVING GOLDSTEIN, AND
RICHARD A. GRASSO,
Defendants, :
-and-
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, :
INC.,
Nominal Defendant.
--------------------------------------x
Norman Monhait
SNIPPETS:
|
|
14
.
BICKELS REPLY BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR JUDGMENT
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
PLAINTIFF COURT PLAN SHARES STOCK SPLITS BICKEL SANDERS CONTRACT PROVISION PARTIES INTERPRETATION LANGUAGE JUDGEMENT AUTHORIZED SHARES MOTIONS COMMITTEE STOCK PRICE PLEADINGS AUTHORITIES BUSINESS JUDGMENT RULE DOLLAR BENEFIT AGREEMENT REVERSE STOCK SPLIT WILLEM VOGEL IRVING GOLDSTEIN RICHARD GRASSO NOMINAL DEFENDANT |
IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
LISA SANDERS,
Plaintiff,
-against-
CHARLES B WANG, SANJAY KUMAR,
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P.
DE VOGEL, IRVING GOLDSTEIN, and
RICHARD A. GRASSO,
Defendants,
-and-
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES
INTERNATIONAL, INC.,
Nominal Defendant. :
---------------------------------------------------------------
EDWARD BICKEL, derivatively on behalf of :
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, :
INC.,
Plaintiff,
-against-
CHARLES B WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, :
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P.
DE VOGEL, IRVING GOLDSTEIN, and
RICHARD A. GRASSO,
Defendants,
-and-
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES
INTERNATIONAL, INC.,
Nominal Defendant. I
PLAINTIFF EDWARD BICKEL'S REPLY BRIEF IN FURTHER
SUPPORT OF HIS MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .ii
I. PRELIMINARY STATEMENT.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . . . .
SNIPPETS:
|
|
15
.
DEFENDANTS REPLY BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS MOTIONS AND ANSWERING BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
PLAINTIFFS AWARD PLAN DEFENDANTS YORK COURT ECONOMIC TERMS APP DIV SHARES DIRECTORS INTERPRETATION SHAREHOLDERS STOCK SPLITS AMDUR COMPENSATION COMMITTEE LIABILITY AGREEMENT COMPLAINT CITATIONS STOCK OPTION PLEADINGS ZAUDERER ELLENHORN FRISCHER SHARP EXEMPT CROMWELL TOWERS REDEVELOPMENT DEBROSSARD |
IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
LISA SANDERS, )
Plaintiff, 11
V. )
)
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, )
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. 1
de VOGEL, RICHARD A. GRASSO, 1
IRVING GOLDSTEIN and SHIRLEY STRUM )
KENNY, )
Defendants, ;civil Action No. 16640
)
-and- ))
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, )
INC., 1
Nominal Defendant. )
-----------_---------------------- )
EDWARD BICKEL, derivatively on ) DEFENDANTS' REPLY BRIEF
behalf of COMPUTER ASSOCIATES ) IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS'
INTERNATIONAL, INC., ) MOTIONS AND ANSWERING BRIEF
) IN OPPOSITION TO BOTH
Plaintiff, ) PLAINTIFFS' MOTIONS
)
V. )
1
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, 1
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P.
DE VOGEL, IRVING GOLDSTEIN, AND 1
RICHARD A. GRASSO, )1
Defendants, ))
-and- ))
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, )
INC., )
Nominal Defendant.
2.
MORRIS, NICHOLS, ARSHT & TUNNELL
Alan J. Stone
Jessica Zeldin
SNIPPETS:
|
|
16
.
DEFENDANTS OPENING BRIEF
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
SHARES BICKEL AMENDED COMPLAINT INTERPRETATION PLAINTIFF DEFENDANTS SANDERS DISMISS COMPENSATION COMMITTEE OPENING AUTHORITY SHAREHOLDERS JUDGEMENT ALLEGES DEMAND COURT YORK READING MOTION INTERVENTION PLEADINGS STOCK SPLITS DEL SUPPORT CONTRACT RATIONALE ADJUSTMENTS BREACH DUTY |
I
,,l".' "
: / ,
THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
LISA SANDERS,
Plaintiff, ))
V . ) Civil Action No. 16640
)
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, )
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P.
de VOGEL, RICHARD A. GRASSO, 1
IRVING GOLDSTEIN and SHIRLEY STRUM )
KENNY, ))
Defendants, ))
-and- ))
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, )
INC., )
Nominal Defendant. )
---------------------------------- ) DEFENDANTS' OPENING BRIEF
EDWARD BICKEL, derivatively on ) IN SUPPORT OF THEIR
behalf of COMPUTER ASSOCIATES ) MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON
INTERNATIONAL, INC., ) THE PLEADINGS AND/OR
) MOTION TO DISMISS
Plaintiff, ) PLAINTIFF BICKEL'S
) AMENDED COMPLAINT
V . )
)
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, )
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. )
DE VOGEL, IRVING GOLDSTEIN, AND )
RICHARD A. GRASSO, ))
Defendants, 11
-and- ))
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, )
INC.,
;
Nominal Defendant. )
MORRIS, NICHOLS, ARSHT & TUNNELL
Alan J. Stone
SNIPPETS:
|
|
17
.
ANSWER TO COMPLAINT
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
KESOP DENY DIRECTORS COURT ADMIT STOCK PLAN RESPECTFULLY REFER PLAINTIFF DEFENDANTS AMENDED COMPLAINT COMMITTEE SHARES SHAREHOLDERS VOGEL AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE PURSUANT LAW OFFICER COMMON STOCK MEMBER AWARD PROXY GRASSO IRVING GOLDSTEIN YORK COMPENSATION RESPONSIVE PLEADING CERTIFICATE |
IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
LISA SANDERS,
Plaintiff,
V . Civil Action No. 16640
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR,
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P.
de VOGEL, RICHARD A. GRASSO,
IRVING GOLDSTEIN and SHIRLEY STRUM
KENNY,
Defendants,
-and-
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL,
INC.,
Nominal Defendant. ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS
---------------------------------- WILLEM F.P. DE VOGEL,
EDWARD BICKEL, derivatively on IRVING GOLDSTEIN,
behalf of COMPUTER ASSOCIATES RICHARD A. GRASSO, AND
INTERNATIONAL, INC., COMPUTER ASSOCIATES, INC.
TO PLAINTIFF BICKEL'S
Plaintiff, AMENDED COMPLAINT
IN INTERVENTION
V .
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR,
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P.
DE VOGEL, IRVING GOLDSTEIN, AND
RICHARD A. GRASSO,
Defendants,
-and-
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL,
INC.,
Nominal Defendant.
Defendants Willem F.P. de Vogel, Irving Goldstein,
SNIPPETS:
|
|
18
.
ANSWER TO COMPLAINT
|
EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
PARAGRAPH DENY ADMIT DIRECTORS STOCK COURT PLAINTIFF DEFENDANTS RESPECTFULLY REFER MEMBER COMMITTEE ARTZT AMENDED COMPLAINT WANG KUMAR INTERVENTION SHARES PURSUANT COMPENSATION COMMON STOCK SHAREHOLDERS PROXY STATEMENT VOGEL GOLDSTEIN LAW SET OFFICER RESPONSIVE PLEADING REASONS CERTIFY |
IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE
----------------------------------------------------------------x 1:
LISA SANDERS, : Civil Action No. 16640
Plaintiff
- against -
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR,
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. DE
VOGEL, RICHARD A. GRASSO, IRVING
GOLDSTEIN and SHIRLEY STRUM KENNY,
Defendants,
-and-
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, :
INC.,
Nominal Defendant.
EDWARD BICKEL, derivatively on behalf of :
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, :
INC.,
Plaintiff,
- against -
CHARLES B. WANG, SANJAY KUMAR, :
RUSSELL M. ARTZT, WILLEM F.P. DE
VOGEL, IRVING GOLDSTEIN, and RICHARD I
A. GRASSO,
Defendants,
-and-
COMPUTER ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, :
INC.,
Nominal Defendant.
___---___-__________------------------------------------- --w-x
ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS WANG, KUMAR AND ARTZT TO PLAINTIFF
BICKEL'S AMENDED COMPLAINT IN INTERVENTION
SNIPPETS:
|
|
|
| | | |
|
|
