LegalCaseDocs.com
shopping cart  
  |     
Search
 

 
New Visitors


 VeriSign Secure Site

 Get Adobe Reader

SIMON v THE NAVELLIER SERIES FUND Click to find out why . . .



Keywords & Phrases
CaseNo: C.A. No. 17,734, CourtCode: CC, CourtName: IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE I, Plaintiff: SIMON, State: DE Delaware, UniqueCaseRef: DE>CC>00017734, Trust, Indemnification, Trustee, Fund, Simon, Trustees, Delaware, Indemnification Agreement, Business Trust, Declaration, Motion, Venue Provision, Navellier, Business Trusts, Forum Selection Clause, Jurisdiction, Chancery, California, Dismiss, Del, Navellier Series Fund, Indemnity, Series Fund, Former Trustees, Underlying Action, Complaint, Connection, Defense, Discovery, Sletten Indemnity Action, Expenses, Fees, James, Chancellor, Lippetz Julie, Spear Street Tower, Authorities, Underlying , ContentID: 120239686

Case Documents
1 2000-10-19 MEMORANDUM OPINION
[ see first page and extracted highlights below  ] ItemID: 100212
26 pages
PDF
2 2000-04-11 PLAINTIFFS ANSWERING BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION TO DISMISS OR STAY
[ see first page and extracted highlights below  ] ItemID: 102584
35 pages
PDF
3 2000-01-12 COMPLAINT
[ see first page and extracted highlights below  ] ItemID: 101442
6 pages
PDF
Total Documents: 3 documents , 67 pages
Price: $ 29.95


IVESLCD01 KGI0001
 
 

 Forgot your password?


1 . MEMORANDUM OPINION

EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
COURT
TRUST
SIMON
TRUSTEES
FUND
PLAINTIFF
BUSINESS TRUSTS
MOTION
INDEMNIFICATION AGREEMENT
CHANCERY
DISMISS
VENUE PROVISION
DECLARATION
FORUM SELECTION CLAUSE
DEFENDANTS
NAVELLIER SERIES FUND
CALIFORNIA
SERIES FUND
JURISDICTION
COMPLAINT
DISCOVERY
ATTORNEYS
JAMES
CHANCELLOR
UNDERLYING
FORMER TRUSTEES
INDEMNITY AGREEMENT
INSTRUMENTS
INTERPRETATION
      IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE i'
                                                                                  $5 J
                                                                                   '  :  '
                     IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY


DONALD SIMON, an ind.ividual and former             >
Trustee of the Navallier Series Fund,               >>
                            Plaintiff,              >
      V.                                            >          Civil Action No. 17734
                                                    >
THE  NAVELLIER SERIES FUND, a Delaware              )
Business Trust, and THE AGGRESSIVE SMALL )
CAP EQUITY PORTFOLIO of the                         >
NAVELILIER PERFORMANCE FUNDS, a.                    >
Delaware Business Trust,                            >>
                            Defendants.             >

                             MEMORANDUM OPINION

                         Date Submitted: August 25, 2000
                            Date Decided: October  19, 2000

Ronald A. Brown, Jr. and Thomas A. Mullen, Esquires, of PRICKETT, JONES &
EELIO'TT,  Wilmington, Delaware; OF COUNSEL: Vincent P. Finigan, Jr.,
Gregory L. Lippetz, and Julie F. Unmacht, Esquires, of BROBECK, PHLEGER &
HARRISON LLP, San Francisco, California, Attorneys for Plaintiff.

Henry N. Herndon, Jr.., P.  Clarkson  Collins, Jr., and Michael A.. Weidinger,
Esquires, of MORRIS, JAMES,  HITCHENS   & WILLIAMS, Wilmington,
Delaware; OF COUNSEL: Samuel Komhauser, Esquire, of  L.A`W OFFICES OF
SAMUE,L KORNBAUSE


SNIPPETS:
 
  • IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE i'
  • Weidinger, Esquires, of MORRIS, JAMES, HITCHENS & WILLIAMS, Wilmington, Delaware; OF COUNSEL:
  • expenses brought by plaintiff Donald Simon, formerly a trustee of the Fund.
  • Simon's indemnification claim arises out of a breach of fiduciary duty
  • action brought iagainst Simon and certain other trustees by several Fund
  • Simon prevailed at trial in the underlying action,
  • ------_--' The Navelher Series Fund is the predecessor in interest to co-defendant Aggressive
  • I will refer to the defendants collectively as "?4avellier" or the "Fund" or "defendant."
  • the Aggressive Small Cap Equity Portfolio is also a business trust.
  • Simon's indemnification agreement with the Fund.
  • indemnification claim based solely on the Fund's declaration of tmst rather
  • the declaration of tmst neither contains a venue provision nor incorporates
  • langu.age of the two .instruments and the objective circumstances of their
  • At the center ofxhis dispute is the Navellier Series Fund,
  • ' L Inote that I reject the Fund's third ground for dismissal: this court's supposed lack of
  • While this appears to be a question of first impression, I am confident that equitable
  • Here, Simon has based his indemnification claim on a declaration of trust executed pursuant
  • other stockholders brought suit against the Former Trustees in California
  • After surviving a motion to dismiss,
  • contains no forum selection clause.
  • passing in his complaint, Sletten argues that the only dlocument
  • Because the indemnity agreement was
  • In the Hut Holding v. Drexel Bumham Lambert" case, Chancellor
  • the c80urt to grant a dismissal motion before the commencement of discovery

  • 2 . PLAINTIFFS ANSWERING BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION TO DISMISS OR STAY

    EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
    TRUSTEE
    DELAWARE
    FUND
    BUSINESS TRUST
    INDEMNIFICATION AGREEMENT
    COURT
    NAVELLIER
    DEL
    DECLARATION
    VENUE PROVISION
    JURISDICTION
    INDEMNITY
    DEFENDANTS
    PLAINTIFFS
    MOTION
    FORUM SELECTION CLAUSE
    UNDERLYING ACTION
    CALIFORNIA
    SLETTEN INDEMNITY ACTION
    FORMER TRUSTEES
    NAVELLIER SERIES FUND
    LIPPETZ JULIE
    SPEAR STREET TOWER
    AUTHORITIES
    MATTER JURISDICTION
    KORNHAUSER AFF
    ATTORNEYS
    GOVERNING INSTRUMENT
    SAN FRANCISCO
    
      IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE                                     //
                             IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
    
    
    DONALD SIMON, an individual and former           )
    Trustee of the Navellier Series Fund,
                                                     j
                           Plaintiff,                {    Civil Action No. 17734-NC
            vs.                                      i
    THE NAVELLIER SERIES FUND, a                     j
    Delaware Business Trust, and THE
    AGGRESSIVE SMALL CAP EQUITY                      j
    PORTFOLIO of the NAVELLIER
    PERFORMANCE FUNDS, a Delaware                    i
    Business Trust,                                  I
                           Defendants.               j
                                                                                 -
    
                               PLAINTIFF'S ANSWERING
                        BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS'  :                          .
              MOTION TO DISMISS OR, ALTERNATIVELY, TO STAY                       r `>
                                                                          ___         i_
                                             PRICKETT, JONES  & ELLIOTT
                                             Ronald A. Brown, Jr.
                                             Thomas ,4. Mullen
                                             1310 King Street
                                             P.O. Box 1328
                                             Wilmington, DE 19899-1328
                                             (302) 888-6500
                                             Attorneys for Plaintiff
    Of Counsel:
    
    BROBECK, PHLEGER & HARRISON LLP
    Vincent P. Finigan, Jr.
    Gregory L. Lippetz
    Julie F. Unmacht
    Spear Street Tower
    One Market
    San Francisco, California 94105
    (415) 442-0900
    
    DATED: APRIL 11, 2000
    
    17120.1\112460v1
    
    
    
                                                                               TABLEOFCONTENTS
    
    
    SNIPPETS:
  • Trustee of the Navellier Series Fund,
  • Delaware Business Trust, and THE
  • Gregory L. Lippetz Julie F. Unmacht
  • Spear Street Tower One Market
  • San Francisco, California 94105
  • TABLE OF AUTHORITIES.
  • THE UNDERLYING ACTION.
  • THE FORMER TRUSTEES COUNTERCLAIM.
  • THE SLETTEN INDEMNITY ACTION.
  • THE DECLARATION OF TRUST AND INDEMNIFICATION
  • PROPER VENUE FOR THIS ACTION IS IN DELAWARE.
  • Standard on the Motion.
  • Contains No Forum Selection Clause.
  • Plaintiffs Claims Are Not Subject to the Venue Provision
  • The Declaration of Trust and the Indemnity
  • Trust and the Indemnification Agreement
  • THIS COURT HAS SUBJECT MATTER JURISDICTION OVER SIMON'S INDEMNIFICATION CLAIMS.

  • 3 . COMPLAINT

    EXTRACTED KEY WORDS
    SIMON
    CONNECTION
    DEFENSE
    TRUSTEE
    TRUST
    EXPENSES
    FEES
    INDEMNIFICATION
    NPF
    DECLARATION
    COURT
    NAVELLIER
    DELAWARE
    ATTORNEYS
    PLAINTIFF
    BUSINESS TRUST
    INVESTMENT
    PAYMENTS
    DEFENDANTS
    CALIFORNIA
    JUDGEMENT
    DISTRICT
    REQUEST
    OBLIGATIONS
    PORTFOLIO
    INVESTMENT COMPANY ACT
    OFFICERS
    REASON
    DUTIES
    
                                                                                     !          /
                                                                 :I,,  :  I  :  _          ,
    
                   IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY FOR THE STATE OF DELAWARE
    
                                   IN AND FOR NEW CASTLE COUNTY
    
    
    
    DONALD SIMON, an individual and former                )
    Trustee of the Navellier Series Fund,
    
                              Plaintiff,
    
            vs.
                                                          j
    THE NAVELLIER SERIES FUND, a
    Delaware Business Trust, and THE
    AGGRESSIVE SMALL CAP EQUITY
    PORTFOLIO of the NAVELLIER
    PERFORMANCE FUNDS, a Delaware
    Business Trust,
    
                              Defendants.
    
                                                 COMPLAINT
    
            Plaintiff, Donald Simon, alleges as follows:
    
                                                   PARTIES
    
             1.         Plaintiff, Donald Simon ("Simon"), is an  in.dividual residing in  Napa,
    
    California. Between May 1992 and July 1997, Simon was a Trustee of the Navellier
    
    Series Fund.
    
            2.          Defendant, the Navellier Series Fund (the "Fund'), is a Delaware
    
    Business Trust registered under the Investment Compan.y  Act of 1940.
    
            3.          Defendant, the Aggressive Small Cap Equity Portfolio of the Navellier
    
    Performance Funds (the "NPF"),  is a Delaware Business Trust registered under the
    
    Investment Company Act of 1940. Plaintiff is informed and believes, and on that
    
    basis alleges, that the NPF is the successor in interest to the Fund.
    
    
    SNIPPETS:
  • IN THE COURT OF CHANCERY FOR THE STATE OF DELAWARE
  • Trustee of the Navellier Series Fund,
  • Delaware Business Trust, and THE
  • PORTFOLIO of the NAVELLIER PERFORMANCE FUNDS,
  • Plaintiff, Donald Simon, alleges as follows:
  • Between May 1992 and July 1997, Simon was a Trustee of the Navellier
  • Business Trust registered under the Investment Compan.y Act of 1940.
  • Investment Company Act of 1940.
  • that the NPF is the successor in interest to the Fund.
  • Declaration of Trust, which organized the Fund as a
  • The Trust shall indemnify each of its Trustees, officers,
  • threatened, while in office or thereafter, by reason of his
  • of his duties.
  • filed an action in the United States District Court for the Northern
  • District of California, entitled McLachlan u. Simon, Case No. 97-1258 WHO, for
  • attorneys' fees and costs incurred in connection with his defense of the Action.
  • the Fund agreed to make advance payments to Simon
  • the Fund for any expenses advanced to him in the event that there was a
  • Simon renewed his request for indemnification from the
  • The Fund and the NPF have breached their obligations to Simon by
  • result of the Defendants' breaches of their obligations.
  • Despite a written request for indemnification following the Judgment
  •    |